The standard Italian rail itinerary — Rome, Florence, Venice, perhaps Milan — is the trip most American visitors take. The trip works; it has worked for decades; it will continue to work. There is, however, a different itinerary, available to visitors willing to commit to a fortnight on the rail network, that produces a fundamentally different kind of trip.
The structure
The structure of the alternative itinerary moves north to south, beginning in Bologna and ending in Lecce. The rail connections are reliable across the route; the smaller cities at each stop reward the kind of slower walking that the broader country has, in its major destinations, made increasingly difficult.
The cities
The cities the itinerary visits include Bologna, Modena, Parma, Mantua, Verona, Padua, Bari, and Lecce, with several smaller stops in between. Each city carries a defined cultural and gastronomic identity that the larger Italian cities, in their adaptation to mass tourism, have substantially homogenised.
The food
The food on the alternative itinerary is one of its central rewards. The smaller cities of Emilia-Romagna in particular — Bologna, Modena, Parma — sit at the centre of the most important Italian food traditions, with restaurants and markets that operate at the level of the country's most serious food culture without being overwhelmed by visitors.
The accommodations
The accommodations across the alternative itinerary are simpler and more reasonable in price than the equivalents on the standard itinerary. Most of the cities carry a small number of well-run hotels in the historic centres; the bookings can be made closer to the trip than the major-city bookings would allow.
The pace
The pace of the trip is the part that visitors trained on the standard itinerary will find most challenging. The alternative itinerary asks for slower walking, longer meals, and more time at lower-stakes activities than the standard itinerary's higher-density sightseeing. The reward is a different kind of acquaintance with the country.
The practical advice
The practical advice is to budget at least fourteen days for the itinerary; ten will not be enough to absorb what the trip is built around. The rail-pass economics work in favour of the longer trip; the day-to-day pacing rewards the patience.